Skip to content
DATA STORY · 2025

Why can zakat distribution exceed collections?

Annual differences need to be read alongside the reporting method and accounting period.

Editorial scene of community assistance and zakat administration records
AI-generated illustration · Editorial interpretation, not a documentary photograph
VISUAL EVIDENCE · DATED DATA

Collections are not distributions

Two annual Federal Territories figures from JAWHAR's 2025 tables. These are comparisons of totals, not a money-flow diagram.

COLLECTIONSRM1.249billion2025 · WP
≠
DISTRIBUTIONSRM1.280billion2025 · WP
Arithmetic difference: RM31.37 million

The RM31.37 million difference does not identify a source of funding; opening balances, adjustments and financial statements would be needed.

01

The Federal Territories example

For 2025 JAWHAR reports approximately RM1.249 billion in collections and RM1.280 billion in distributions for the Federal Territories. Distribution exceeding annual collection is not by itself evidence of mismanagement; the two series are not identical accounting concepts.

02

What the figures cannot show

Without opening balances, adjustments and closing balances, we cannot identify the source of every ringgit distributed. Nor can we assume unspent current-year receipts are unused funds. An institution's audited statements and accounting notes are needed.

03

Comparing states responsibly

Use the same period, mark unpublished numbers clearly and inspect beneficiary breakdowns where available. Such comparisons are more useful than rankings with no context, particularly when states operate different forms of assistance.

04

A difference that can be calculated

Federal Territories collections for 2025 were RM1,248,551,539.97 and reported distributions were RM1,279,920,930.00. The arithmetic difference is RM31,369,390.03, about RM31.37 million. The calculation compares two published numbers, but does not reveal how the higher distribution was financed.

05

Asnaf details give context, not an audit

The Federal Territories distribution table separates allocations to fakir, miskin, amil, muallaf and other asnaf categories. It helps readers see broad uses of funds, but does not show opening balances, cash flows or accounting recognition policies. Claims about institutional performance require audited financial statements and notes.

06

Statement evidence: Selangor in 2023 and 2024

LZS's statement records exact collections of RM1,118,913,991 in 2023 and RM1,218,086,883 in 2024. Its 2024 distributions were RM1,187,571,818, RM30,515,065 lower than collections that year. This difference is not a closing fund balance or necessarily unused money; the accounting notes and fund balances are needed. LZS's verified amounts also fill a gap where JAWHAR had not published Selangor's 2024 collection figure.

07

Collection types must not be confused with distributions

JAWHAR breaks down Federal Territories' 2025 collections into RM1,231,875,325.02 of zakat harta and RM16,676,214.95 of fitrah, totalling RM1,248,551,539.97. Johor reports RM420,450,524.61 in zakat harta and RM28,552,848.88 in fitrah, totalling RM449,003,373.49. These classify incoming collections; they do not describe asnaf distributions or measure a state's distribution performance. MUIS Sabah reports RM133,968,237.00 collected and RM182,135,889.76 distributed in 2025. PulseKita uses MUIS's complete 2021–2025 Sabah series because JAWHAR's earlier Sabah collection figures differ materially. Melaka's 2025 distribution of RM160,077,622 comes from MAIM; the small collection discrepancy between MAIM and JAWHAR is flagged rather than silently merged. A separate analysis divides each year's zakat collections or distributions by the matched DOSM population estimate; the Federal Territories denominator combines Kuala Lumpur, Labuan and Putrajaya. RM per resident is a statistical ratio using all residents, not zakat paid per payer, aid received per beneficiary, or a measure of institutional effectiveness. JAWHAR's older Federal Territories archive reports RM60,323,536 distributed in 2005. However, DOSM shows RM526,470,917 distributed for the Federal Territories in 2020, versus RM732,558,913 in JAWHAR's state-specific table. Accordingly, changes across DOSM's older series and the post-2020 JAWHAR series must not be presented as reconciled growth. Earlier collections are documented in a Selangor State Assembly answer: all 14 jurisdictions appear for 2008–2011 but only 11 in 2012. The data are marked unaudited; Selangor's 2008–2010 values differ between tables within the same answer. MAIS reports Selangor collections of RM627,220,773 in 2015 and RM673,736,282 in 2016. We keep the 2008–2012 and 2017–2025 bar races separate rather than pretending the 2013–2016 gap is fully comparable.

Verifiable sources

Open the original publications for definitions and coverage. Figures here are not live data.

Sources reviewed: 14 November 2026

Where does zakat money go?
← Back to series